Administrative Court: Urgent application against building permit for ski slope construction at Fellhorn unsuccessful
In this story
Oberstdorf
Resort in Bavaria, Germany
- Village height
- 918 m
- Top lift
- 1,965 m
- Pistes
- 31 km
- Lifts
- 12
- Nearest airport
- Memmingen Allgau Airport (FMM) · 1h 18m
The Administrative Court of Augsburg, in a decision has rejected an urgent application by the Bavarian State Association for Bird and Nature Conservation against a building permit granted to Fellhornbahn GmbH for the construction of the Bierenwang and Walsergund downhill ski slopes.
The building permit in dispute concerns slope construction measures in the Fellhorn cable car area at the so-called Bierenwang descent towards the Walsergund descent and a widening of the slopes in the Scheidtobel.
The responsible 4th Chamber, in the preliminary injunction proceedings, concluded that the building permit is likely lawful. According to the Chamber, the planned construction measures do not conflict with any soil or nature conservation interests; they do not violate either the Soil Protection Protocol of the Alpine Convention or the provisions of habitat or species protection. Furthermore, the requirements of the Allgäu Regional Plan and spatial planning regulations have been observed.
According to expert opinions, the areas specifically affected by the ski slope construction measures are not considered unstable areas within the meaning of the Alpine Convention. The project-specific assessment by the experts, which is based on the criteria of the so-called Tyrolean Checklist, is legally sound. Habitat protection is also ensured because, after review by the Chamber, it can be assumed that the project is not expected to significantly impair the conservation objectives of the affected Natura 2000 sites. In particular, the expert assessment of the impacts on protected habitat types and species, specifically the black grouse and the ptarmigan, was carried out correctly.
The protective and compensatory measures stipulated in the building permit ensured that no significant adverse effects occurred. No errors were found in the species protection assessment of the project. The identification and inventory of existing animal species were also carried out correctly in this respect. Mandatory avoidance measures, construction schedules, measures to protect adjacent structures, and the limitation of the construction area would reduce construction-related disturbances. In addition, measures for visitor management and concentration on designated hiking trails were implemented; the nature conservation restrictions were therefore observed. The Higher Nature Conservation Authority (Government of Swabia) granted the additional special species protection exemption required after the building permit was issued; no appeal was lodged against this decision.
An appeal against the preliminary injunction (Au 4 S 26.1000) may be lodged with the Bavarian Administrative Court of Appeal within two weeks. The lawsuit and the application for preliminary injunction against the separate permit for the lift expansion of the Scheidtobelbahn cable car remain pending before the 6th Chamber of the Augsburg Administrative Court.