Independent voices. A mountain perspective. The winter edition26 / 27

Find your mountain story.

Snow News

Augsburg Administrative Court partially grants application by Bavarian State Association for Bird and Nature Conservation against new Scheidtobel cable car at Fellhorn.

Augsburg Administrative Court partially grants application by Bavarian State Association for Bird and Nature Conservation against new Scheidtobel cable car at Fellhorn.

In this story

Oberstdorf

Resort in Bavaria, Germany

Village height
918 m
Top lift
1,965 m
Pistes
31 km
Lifts
12
Nearest airport
Memmingen Allgau Airport (FMM) · 1h 18m
Oberstdorf guide

The Augsburg Administrative Court partially granted the urgent application filed by the Bavarian State Association for Bird and Nature Conservation (LBV) against the construction of the new Scheidtobel cable car at Fellhorn. Construction of the new cable car is to be temporarily halted, while the slope construction work can continue.

“The Augsburg Administrative Court’s ruling demonstrates one thing above all: legal uncertainty is problematic for everyone involved. Companies need reliable and legally sound permitting processes so that infrastructure projects can be planned economically and with long-term security. Furthermore, the public sometimes gets the impression that cable car projects without a mandatory environmental impact assessment are not subject to comprehensive environmental review. This impression is incorrect. Regardless of an environmental impact assessment, cable car projects in Germany always undergo comprehensive nature conservation and species protection assessments as well as official permitting procedures,” said Birgit Priesnitz, Managing Director of the German Cable Car Association (VDS).

Follow the story
What's next for Oberstdorf?

Get Oberstdorf news by email.

Follow Oberstdorf

The construction and operating permit for the Scheidtobel cable car was granted following the amendments to the Third Bavarian Modernization Act. Under these provisions, an environmental impact assessment (EIA) was not required for the cable car and was therefore not conducted. The decisive factor in the ruling is whether this amendment is compatible with European law and the jurisprudence of the European Court of Justice. This complex legal question cannot be definitively resolved in preliminary injunction proceedings and is reserved for subsequent litigation. For this reason, the balancing of interests in the preliminary injunction proceedings favored the Bavarian State Office for Road Construction and Transport (LBV), resulting in a temporary halt to the cable car's construction. The court thus makes no statement regarding the legality of the project and no general ruling on the Third Bavarian Modernization Act. At the same time, the court's reasoning clarifies that the Third Bavarian Modernization Act has not led to a substantive weakening of environmental standards.

Even if a project is not subject to an environmental impact assessment (EIA), nature and species conservation is an integral part of the official approval procedures for cable car projects in Germany. This includes ecological surveys (fauna and flora) throughout the entire vegetation period, planning and evaluation via the landscape management plan (LBP), the specific species protection assessment (saP), and, where applicable, FFH and EIA reports, coordination with specialist authorities for nature conservation, water management, and forestry, as well as environmental construction supervision during the construction phase to ensure that protection and avoidance measures are consistently implemented.

The VDS therefore advocates for a timely legal clarification in order to create planning certainty for an industry that continuously invests in sustainable infrastructure and combines ecological, social and economic responsibility.

https://www.seilbahnen.de/

Directory

Indy Pass Recco Leitner Zeal Tirol Halti ISPO Technoalpin