Colorado Supreme Court upholds dismissal of lawsuit against Vail Resorts over Epic Pass waiver
In this story
Partners mentioned
Vail
Resort in Colorado, United States
- Village height
- 2,490 m
- Top lift
- 3,526 m
- Pistes
- 215 km
- Lifts
- 32
- Nearest airport
- Eagle County Regional Airport (EGE) · 47m
A divided Colorado Supreme Court has ruled that a snowboarder gave up his right to pursue claims against Vail Resorts when he later purchased an Epic Pass—despite the fact that the accident had occurred nearly two years earlier.
The September 21 decision in Litterer v. Vail Summit Resorts ends a closely watched dispute over the reach of ski-pass liability waivers in Colorado. The court held that John Litterer’s purchase of a 2022–23 Epic Pass created an enforceable post-injury release covering claims arising from a 2020 collision at Breckenridge Ski Resort.
The ruling means Litterer’s lawsuit against Vail Summit Resorts and Dwight McClure, the company employee involved in the incident, remains dismissed. The decision was issued by a 6–3 court, with Justice Berkenkotter writing the majority opinion. Chief Justice Marquez and Justices Boatright and Blanco joined the opinion, while Justice Gabriel filed a dissent joined by Justices Hood and Samour.
The accident and the later pass purchase
Litterer was snowboarding at Breckenridge in December 2020 when he collided with a snowmobile driven by McClure, a Vail Resorts employee. Litterer subsequently brought legal claims against Vail Summit Resorts and McClure, arguing that the defendants were responsible for the circumstances that led to the crash.
While that case was still active, Litterer decided to return to Breckenridge. In 2022, he bought a five-day Epic Pass for the coming ski season through Vail Resorts’ online purchasing system.
As part of the transaction, he accepted a liability agreement that stated, in capital letters, that the pass holder agreed to waive “any and all claims” against the company and its employees, to the greatest extent permitted by law. The agreement also included a release, indemnity and promise not to sue the covered parties.
Vail Resorts later argued that Litterer’s new agreement released the claims arising from the earlier accident. A Summit County District Court accepted that argument and dismissed the remaining claims with prejudice in January 2024. The Colorado Court of Appeals affirmed the decision in January 2025.
Why the court treated the waiver as enforceable
The central issue before the Colorado Supreme Court was not whether Litterer had signed a waiver before the 2020 accident. Instead, the court considered whether he had entered into a valid release after the accident had already happened and while his lawsuit was pending.
The majority distinguished the case from Miller v. Crested Butte, a 2024 decision involving an injured skier whose pre-injury waiver was found not to cover certain claims under Colorado’s Ski Safety Act. In Litterer, the court held that the Epic Pass agreement was a post-injury release governed by ordinary contract principles, rather than a pre-injury exculpatory agreement.
That distinction was decisive. Because Litterer purchased the pass after the collision, the court concluded that the agreement could release claims that already existed, provided the contract was valid and its language was sufficiently clear.
The ruling also affirmed the lower courts’ conclusion that allegations of willful and wanton conduct and requests for exemplary damages were not independent causes of action that could proceed separately.
A dispute over how far waivers can reach
The case had drawn attention because of the breadth of the waiver language and its potential implications for injured skiers and snowboarders who later return to a resort.
During oral arguments, Litterer’s attorney, Trent Ongert, argued that Vail Resorts should not be able to use a later pass purchase to erase claims connected to alleged violations of Colorado safety laws. He contended that the case offered the court an opportunity to clarify the limits of its earlier ruling in Miller.
Vail Resorts’ attorney, Michael Hofmann, responded that Colorado is a “freedom of contract” state and that adults should be held to agreements they accept. He argued that the Epic Pass language was prominently presented and did not release claims involving gross negligence or violations of state safety laws.
The justices themselves questioned whether a skier would reasonably understand that buying a new season pass could affect an existing lawsuit. Justice William Hood described the result as potentially unfair, suggesting that a customer might not expect a dense pass agreement to waive claims connected to an earlier incident.
Hofmann countered that Litterer could have declined to purchase the Epic Pass. Instead, he chose to return to the resort and accepted the conditions attached to access. Allowing him to escape that promise simply because he may not have read the agreement, Hofmann argued, could undermine the stability of contract law.
Broader consequences for ski-pass contracts
The ruling does not eliminate Colorado’s earlier limits on pre-injury waivers. Instead, it establishes a significant distinction between agreements signed before an accident and releases accepted afterward.
For ski resorts, the decision reinforces the value of clearly worded pass agreements that define the scope of a customer’s obligations. For skiers and snowboarders, it underlines that the terms of a season pass may have consequences beyond the immediate decision to access the mountain.
The case also highlights a tension at the heart of ski-area liability law. Resorts rely on waivers to manage the risks inherent in skiing and snowboarding, while injured participants argue that those contracts should not shield operators from responsibility for conduct that falls outside the ordinary risks of the sport.
Colorado’s ski industry has long operated within that debate. The state’s Ski Safety Act establishes duties and protections for ski-area operators, but courts continue to determine how those statutory obligations interact with private contracts.
In this case, the Supreme Court’s majority concluded that the answer turned on timing. Litterer was not asked to surrender future claims before he was injured; he accepted the release after the collision, while his case was pending. By purchasing the Epic Pass, the court held, he entered into a new agreement that covered the claims he was pursuing.
The decision offers Vail Resorts a legal victory, but it is unlikely to end the wider argument over ski-pass waivers. The dissent and the questions raised during oral arguments show that the boundary between assumed sporting risk, contractual release and resort accountability remains contested—particularly when a pass agreement reaches back to an accident that has already occurred.